Crumbl Cookies: September 2025 Menu and Spoilers

Crumbl Cookies keeps dessert lovers excited with a fresh menu every week. For September 2025, fans can look forward to fall themed treats, returning favorites, and some limited time surprises. Here’s a full breakdown of this month’s confirmed cookies, spoiler predictions, and tasty tips!

What Makes Crumbl Cookies Special?

Crumbl Cookies started in 2017 in Logan, Utah, when two cousins Sawyer Hemsley and Jason McGowan had an idea for a modern bakery. Today, Crumbl has over 1,000 stores across the U.S. and Canada. What makes Crumbl different? Every Monday, the cookie lineup changes with new, creative flavors.

Fans tune in every Sunday night at 8:00 PM EST to see the new cookie reveal on Crumbl’s TikTok and Instagram. Spoilers early leaks of upcoming flavors make the wait even more exciting!

A Classic Favorite

Crumbl’s Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie is one of the only cookies available every single week. While other flavors rotate weekly, this one is a permanent menu item because it’s just that good. It’s the cookie people come back for again and again.

The cookie is soft in the center, slightly crispy on the edges, and always served warm (unless you ask otherwise). What makes it different from other chocolate chip cookies? The size, the texture, and the use of Ghirardelli quality milk chocolate chips that melt perfectly in every bite.

Confirmed Menu: September 1–5, 2025

Here’s the official cookie lineup for the first week of September:

• New Brownie (NCD): A rich, fudgy brownie dessert not a cookie, but a must-try!
  
• New Sandwich Cookie: Two cookies with a creamy center a new twist from Crumbl.
  
• Caramel Pumpkin Cake Cookie: A spiced pumpkin cookie with caramel drizzle cozy fall in cookie form.
  
• Sugar Cookie ft. Mother’s Circus Animal: A colorful sugar cookie topped with crushed Circus Animal cookies fun and nostalgic.
  
• Biscoff Ice Cream Cookie: Cookie butter flavor with a creamy topping tastes like a frozen treat.
  
• Kentucky Butter Cake Cookie: Soft, buttery, and glazed just like the Southern classic dessert.
  
• Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie: The original Crumbl classic crispy edges, gooey chocolate, and always a favorite.
  

These flavors are available from Monday, September 1 to Saturday, September 5. Some stores may have slight differences in availability.

September 2025 Spoilers: What’s Coming?

The full monthly menu hasn’t been confirmed yet, but fans are already spotting clues online. Based on fan pages and past trends, here are some cookies that might be coming later in September:

• Pumpkin Square: A warm, cake-like pumpkin treat perfect for fall.
  
• S’mores Brownie (NCD): Marshmallow, graham cracker, and chocolate all in one gooey brownie.
  
• The Afterlife Cake (LTO): A spooky cookie inspired by the Beetlejuice Beetlejuice movie possibly with fun toppings.
  
• Cookies & Cream Milkshake ft. Mini Oreo: A creamy cookie with Oreo pieces like a milkshake in cookie form.
  
• Strawberry Chocolate Cheesecake (NCD): A fruity and chocolatey cheesecake dessert.
  
• Peanut Butter Pretzel Brownie (NCD): A sweet and salty brownie with peanut butter and pretzel crunch.
  
• Top Secret Flavor: Rumors say a mystery cookie may arrive at the end of September, possibly a celebrity collab or brand-new creation.
  

These are all based on fan predictions, social media leaks, and insider tips. But Crumbl might change the lineup if leaks spread too early so stay tuned to their official channels.

Why Spoilers Are a Big Deal

Spoilers are a huge part of the Crumbl community. They help fans plan their cookie trips ahead of time especially when popular flavors might sell out fast. Here’s where spoilers usually come from:

Social Media

TikTok and Reddit users like @sweetcrumblspoilers or the r/CrumblCookies subreddit often post early flavor hints.

Fan Blogs

Websites like crumblmenu.com and crumblcookiesweekmenu.us share weekly predictions and past flavor patterns.

Insider Tips

Sometimes Crumbl employees or taste testers drop clues on forums though not always 100% accurate.

Tips to Enjoy Crumbl Cookies

Here are some smart tips to get the most out of Crumbl’s September menu:

• Order early: Popular cookies often sell out. Visit early in the week or use the app to pre-order.
  
• Try mini cookies: A fun way to sample more flavors without eating full-size cookies.
  
• Check allergen info: Crumbl lists common allergens (like nuts, dairy, or gluten) on their website.
  
• Join the loyalty program: Earn rewards points with each purchase using the Crumbl app.
  
• Freeze extras: Crumbl cookies freeze well for up to 3 months—save your favorites for later!
  

Why September 2025 Is a Sweet Month

September at Crumbl Cookies is packed with warm, cozy flavors like pumpkin and caramel plus fun surprises like Afterlife Cake and mystery cookies. Whether you’re checking spoilers or waiting for the official weekly reveal, every Monday brings something fresh and delicious.